Saturday, November 24, 2012
Wednesday, November 21, 2012
Ethical Issues Might Exist Within Polygraph Examinations
A concise
introduction to polygraph testing:
A polygraph, sometimes called a lie detector, measures and
records a subject’s blood pressure, pulse, respiration, and skin conductivity
while he or she is questioned. The idea is that if a subject responds to a
question with a deceiving response the polygraph will show physiological reactions
that are different from non-deceiving responses. John Augustus Larson invented
the polygraph in 1921; he was a medical student at the University of California
at Berkeley. It was first implemented within law enforcement by August Vollmer,
the police chief of the Berkeley Police Department in Berkeley, California.
Many members of the scientific community consider polygraphy to be
pseudoscience, or a practice that is presented as scientific but: does not
adhere to a valid scientific method, lacks supporting evidence or plausibility,
and or cannot be reliably tested. However, in some countries, polygraphy is
still being used as an interrogation tool during criminal investigations. It is
also being used to supplement the interview process of prospective employees
for certain public and or private sector jobs. In the United States, federal
government agencies such as the FBI, the CIA, and many police departments, including
the Los Angeles Police Department, are using polygraph examinations to question
suspects and also to screen potential new recruits. However, in Massachusetts,
Maryland, New Jersey, Delaware and Iowa it is illegal for a non-government
employer to administer a polygraph examination. Further, polygraph testimony’s
admissibility in court differs between each state, and its admissibility is
typically up to the discretion of the judge. Yet, no defendant or witness can
be forced to undergo a polygraph test. While its use in court is controversial,
polygraphy is widely used during probation, particularly on sex offenders.
Interview of
criminology & criminal justice professor Tom Mauriello (polygraphy expert):
The potential ethical
issues that could arise during polygraph examinations:
Some concluding thoughts on polygraphy:
Monday, November 19, 2012
Friday, November 9, 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)